50th anniversary emblem

Until March to counter draft management

Plan to relegate coastal trail

Cimino 21 November 2015

Anybody who’d read the summary of phase-1 submissions would be utterly flummoxed.

Of the 140 who made submissions to the Auckland Regional Parks management plan, 101 explicitly supported the concept for a Mahurangi Coastal Trail as the primary access to Te Muri, and only two requested car access. Despite this, the draft plan baldly asserts:

While there was support in the feedback not to provide vehicle access into the park, this is required to fully utilise the council’s significant investment in this park and make it as available as possible to all sectors of the community.

Draft Te Muri concept plan Backcountry Camping Beside Car Park: Professional planners who have taken a quick look at the draft Te Muri management plan are confident that Mahurangi Coastal Trail proponents have been provided with the opportunity for robust argument. An example of the plan’s incoherence is the main vehicular arrival area sited smack beside the ‘backcountry’ campground. Fortunately, even if such absurdities find their way into the final plan, the $4 million-plus cost of upgrading Hungry Creek Road and the Schischka farm road will ensure the spectre of parking for thousands of cars will never materialise—long since vanquished by the success of the Mahurangi Coastal Trail. Image Auckland Council
It does the objectivity of its authors no credit that only those who read to within the last 5 pages of the 39-page draft management plan would be aware the support in the feedback mentioned on page 4 was so emphatically and overwhelmingly opposed to vehicular access. As for the contention that vehicle access is required to fully utilise the council’s investment, this both unsupported and ignores the rich opportunity for Te Muri to be the jewel in the crown of the greater Mahurangi regional park attracting potentially more visitors year-round than by car access because of the popularity of being able, for example, to walk from Waiwera to Puhoi, before bussing home, with or without an overnight camping experience and a side trip to Sullivans Bay. Instead, road access is steadfastly supported:

The plan provides for a staged development of the park to provide for recreational use. This will initially hinge on improvements being made to Hungry Creek Road and the intersection with State Highway 1. It is proposed an arrival area be developed at the entrance to the park and that as resources permit the central road would be upgraded and a primary arrival area would be developed, set back from the beach.

The absolute capacity of Te Muri is largely determined by the area available for picnicking and camping within reasonable proximity to the beach, which is about 12 of the 471 hectares of Te Muri parkland. To sacrifice any of this prime parkland for car parking would be to fail to ‘fully utilise the council’s significant investment.’

The process of reviewing the Auckland Regional Parks management plan, to include the 2010 Schischka farm purchase, entitles the public to only two opportunities to make submissions or objections. The first phase ran from mid-July to 19 August, when initial views were invited. During the next stage, which is scheduled to open in early December and close in early March, involves formal submissions. Then, after independent commissioners report a ‘final decision’ in June 2016, that decision would be, in all probability, final—the only avenues open beyond that would be a revolt by the councillors, or a trip to the High Court over a procedural issue.

A similar process was run in 1988, prior to the opening to the public of the coastal margin of Te Muri, which had been purchased in 1973. In that case however, the draft management plan reflected the public’s opposition to providing the road access and car parking that had been mooted, for 2000 cars. Where that process differed greatly from the current one, was that before council officers went to work producing a draft, the public’s initial submissions went before the regional authority’s citizens advisory group. The advisory group was chaired by Judge Arnold Turner, one of the two fathers of the Auckland Regional Parks network, and the man who had drafted the clauses in the regional authority empowering act that gave it license to purchase, 50 years ago, Wenderholm Regional Park. The advisory group was impressed by the comprehensive joint submission made by the community that laid out a convincing plan for walking access only. Ironically, one of the measures contained in the community plan was for a car park partway down the hill from the end of Ngarewa drive, which finally appears in the current draft plan, 27 years later.

Draft Te Muri concept plan Expensive, Dangerous and Nasty: To use Hungry Creek Road and the Schischka farm road as vehicular access to Te Muri would be to render the potential missing section of Te Araroa, the national walkway, unfit for service. To expect walkers to share the, in places excessively steep, and for the most part tortuous, road with horse floats and mobile homes is nothing short of madness, particularly given the coherent alternative of using the proposed Mahurangi Coastal Trail as the primary access for Te Muri. Image Auckland Council
Where the current draft plan does excel, in comparison to that of 1988, is the proposed Judge Arnold Turner Footbridge does get a mention, even if it is relegated to item 26:

Investigate, and if feasible and resources permit, develop design options to enable pedestrians and cyclists to cross Puhoi River, linking the Wenderholm and Te Muri track systems; taking into consideration the following factors:

Despite inclusion of this investigation, the job of the Mahurangi Coastal Trail Trust just got a whole lot harder than it had reason to suppose, and not helped by the woolly advocacy the draft plan attributes to the Rodney Local Board, for vehicle access ‘for families’—the mind boggles as to how families would be defined, identified and separately granted car access.

At this 50-year juncture in the history of the Auckland Regional Parks network, for those who have a coherent vision for the greater Mahurangi regional park, what should have been a summer of optimism for a fresh new approach to equitable and sustainable park access has just become an uncalled-for struggle against the wills of unelected, we-know-what’s-best-for-Aucklanders, council officers.

What should have been a summer of optimism has just become a summer of desperate summer of organising, meeting and submission writing, and more organising, meeting and submission rewriting.

What should have been a summer of optimism has become a battle for Auckland’s New Chums.

Tweet this piece

All, or mostly, about the Mahurangi Coastal Trail

 21-Year-Old President Rocks Coastal Trail Dream for Untouched Paradise
 In the New Zealand Herald : Coastal Trail Dream for Untouched Paradise
 In the New Zealand Herald in PDF format: Coastal Trail Dream for Untouched Paradise
 Initial-Feedback Summary Strongly Confirms Support for Coastal Trail as Primary Te Muri Access
 Taking Te Araroa and the Coastal Trail Cross-Harbour Ferry to AGM
 Re-Imagining the Mahurangi Regatta Beyond the Coastal Trail
 Recurring Regional Parks Rear-Guard Action or Help Lead the 50-Year-Plan Charge
 Without Friends 50th Celebrations Might Have Been Requiem for Regional Parks Network
 World Cup Causes Celebrity Fundraiser to be Rescheduled for 15 November
 Mahurangi Action Provisional Te Muri Regional Park Phase 1 Submission
 Views Sought in First Phase of Planning Long-Term Future of Te Muri
 In the Rodney Times : Coastal Trail Could Bridge the Pūhoi River
 Need for a 15 Nov Mahurangi Coastal Trail Celebrity Fundraiser 1-Pager
 Opportunity to Embolden Parks Chief by Bussing in Bridge Supporters
 How Trail Can Help Save a Habitable Planet
 Three Separate vs. One Magnificent Mahurangi Regional Park
 Roll On the Regional Parks Rolling 50th Celebrations
 Invitation to Informal Celebratory Wenderholm Sunrise Breakfast
 Coastal Trail Trustees Sign On and Board Votes to Support
 Second Concrete Step Taken as the Coastal trail Wins Friends
 Next Step on Coastal Trail is Trust and Working Group
 Calendarise Mahurangi Coastal Trail 15 Nov. Celebrity Fundraiser
 Council Investigates Possibility of Mahurangi Coastal Trail
 Coastal Trail Gains its First Concrete Step
 Mahurangi Coastal Trail High-Tide Seaweek Walk
 Low-Tide Walk to Sample Low-Hanging Fruit
 First Draft of Report for Coastal Trail Discussion at Club
 $15‍ ‍Million Te Muri Purchase Lucky Te Araroa Break
 Ten Minutes and Local Board Agrees to Walk
 The Coastal Path and the Ferrymen
 After a Century or More Ferrymen to Work Sunday
 Road Would Ruin Future for Mahurangi Coastal Trail
 Submission Suggests City as Green Growth Capital
 Unique Role for Mahurangi and Public Transport
 Te Muri Acquisition Key to Coastal Trail
 Captain Jones’ Legacy Complete at Te Muri
 Link Waiwera to Mahurangi with Coastal Cycle Trail

Mahurangi Coastal Trail Technical Document

Part of a hope-based network restoring and enjoying the Mahurangi

I’ll let you be in my dreams if I can be in yours
Bob Dylan 1963

Editor Cimino Cole