Only honourable option

To oppose in full

Cimino 16 April 2014

Harold Wanless, field assistant Layaan Cross for Young to Bear: While the latest report of Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change is claimed by some to be alarmist, it is in fact ‘tragically conservative’. Here a field assistant of Professor Harold Wanless, who is an expert on Miami’s vulnerability to sea-level rise, carries a core sampler into position. Image University of Miami
The best strategy might have been to support the proposal in full.

That way, the Pühoi–Warkworth motorway board of inquiry might have been more receptive to the opportunity for a large-scale trial of open-ground indigenous plants—realistically, the only impact the society is likely to have on the project.

Mahurangi Action, however, chose to not beat about the bush, and opposed the proposed motorway in full, including because of its short- and long-term contribution to greenhouse gas emissions, to which road transport, globally, is the single biggest contributor. It is projected that anthropogenic global warming will bring extreme rainfall events of increasing frequency and intensity, which can only exacerbate the Mahurangi Harbour’s already elevated sediment accumulation rate.

In addition to the long-term impact on the catchment, construction of the motorway will expose the harbour to its greatest influx of sediment since deforestation, should extreme rainfall events coincide with peak open earthworks. The risk, Mahurangi Action has been assured, is statistically very low, but it ultimately comes down to luck. On average, only slightly more than one storm of tropical origin per year hits Northland or Auckland, with most striking in February and March, but luck can be cruel. On 27 February 2004, the day the Warkworth Rotary International was attempting to hold the 18th of its hugely successful charity regattas at Kawau Island, the event was bankrupted by a weather bomb, and hasn’t been held since. A month earlier, Mahurangi Action had held a one-off Mahurangi Regatta Ball, as the grand finale a summer of events celebrating the 150th anniversary of Warkworth’s founding. This was the stimulus for reviving the Mahurangi Regatta Prize-Giving Dance, which, along with the regatta, had ceased during World War II. Mindful of the Kawau Island catastrophe, where marquees were ripped up and deposited into the trees, the society took pains with the format so that cancellation of an event would not prove financially ruinous. But rather enjoy Rotary’s 17-year run, it was only the seventh summer before Wilma scored a direct hit on the Mahurangi Regatta. And besides the weather being too heavy for even the most gung-ho of sailors to set sail from the Waitematä, the road to the regional park, where thousands of picnic-packing regatta spectators would otherwise have gathered at Sullivans Bay, was all but severed by a subsidence.

Belief in Anthropogenic Climate Change by Age Age and Anthropogenic Global Warming: The implications of greenhouse gas emissions are neither intuitive nor palatable, as so graphically displayed here in the trend for younger people to be better, than those older, at understanding the moral issue of the millennium. Chart Crikey
That State Highway 1 between Pühoi and Wellsford is inadequate and dangerous is, of course, not disputed. But the quickest way to reduce head-on crashes on that road is by immediately installing wire-rope median barriers, and other proven and cost-effective measures detailed by the Campaign for Better Transport in its Operation Lifesaver document. Longer term, much smarter and less greenhouse-gas-emitting solutions exist, to the capacity limitations of the existing highway, than extending the motorway farther and farther north. An immediate measure would be to prohibit, on holiday weekends, the use of passing lanes except by emergency vehicles and buses. The reason that the Northern Busway is such a success is that its patrons know that they are enjoying the better mode transportation, as they sail by literally looking down their noses at the unfortunate motorists, mostly one to a car, barely moving in lane after lane of peak traffic. By being prohibited from using passing lanes, motorists will be given pause to consider travelling to their holiday destination by coach, in the relaxed company of family and friends, and a considerable cause of holiday road-rage and accidents would be eliminated. To boot, the benefit to emergency vehicles is obvious. Prioritising passing lanes in this way would be complimentary to the increasing use of urban bus lanes, which itself could be substantially enhanced with active transit signal priority systems, whereby traffic lights prioritise the passage of buses through intersections.

During weekdays, the proposed motorway would largely be used by commuting motorists, given that Auckland Council has ordained that Warkworth is to be a satellite growth centre, in what appears to have been passive acceptance of the government’s roads of national significance programme, directly contrary to its avowed compact city imperative. Meantime, the smart use of commuter buses between Warkworth and a Northern Busway station is already considerably overdue.

In 2004, the Auckland Regional Council announced a 5-year ‘Mahurangi Action Plan’ to kick-start riparian fencing and planting, following 10 years of studies it had commissioned to benchmark a catchment subject to very little development pressure. The regional council knew a lot about catchments subject large-scale earthworks, and expected Mahurangi’s to be near pristine. The stress observed in the benthic communities was such that, in some of the areas studied, cockles and horse mussels had ceased breeding completely. At first blush, the regional council’s $3‍ ‍million budget seemed generous. However, from a handbook on riparian restoration it distributed, published with support from Fonterra, two things were clear: If all the rivers, streams, seeps and wetlands that should be fenced and planted were, the budget would barely scratch the surface; and the cost of indigenous plants was an eye-watering ten times greater than for good quality radiata pine seedlings.

Access road Going the Extra Mile: Rather than build a mile-long access road along the steep hillside between the proposed motorway and the Mahurangi River, generating further sediment, the New Zealand Transport Agency should be creating a broad riparian management zone, planted in indigenous trees, including to help offset a modicum of the greenhouse gases the project would generate, during and after its construction. Aerial NZTA
The quest to understand why radiata pine was so economic led to Dr David Bergin, late of crown research institute Scion, and former Forest Research Institute head nurseryman Jaap van Dorsser. The explanation for the price difference was the fundamentally different nursery methods employed. Radiata pine seedlings are raised ‘from the tractor seat’ in large open-ground beds, their root systems mechanically pruned and conditioned subterraneously before being lifted bare-rooted for transplantation. From the late 1950s, van Dorsser successfully adapted the radiata pine method, which he’d initially developed for eucalypts, for the large-scale production of indigenous species. Tens of thousands of plants were raised and established with the method, but due to the subsequent privatisation of the New Zealand Forest Service, this work on indigenous species, which should have resulted in a sustainable indigenous forestry industry, was discontinued.

A $135‍ ‍000 grant to Mahurangi Action by the Sustainable Farming Fund enabled the first-ever scientifically designed trials to compare the establishment performance of open-ground and container raised indigenous plants. The trials, conducted in the Mahurangi and Weiti catchments, which successfully demonstrated that open-ground indigenous plants established as successfully as their much more expensive planter bag or pot raised counterparts. This work was noticed by the Lake Taupö Protection Trust, which funded further trials that, in addition to confirming those in the Auckland region, revealed that the planting costs of the open-ground plants were halved—a planter could carry four to five times the number of plants. Supplier of the plants for all the trials, Taupö Native Plant Nursery, can now offer open-ground plants, for large-scale plantings, at a fifth of the cost of pot or planter bag raised plants. Hillson root trainer raised plants were also involved in both sets of trials, but performed so poorly as to not be cost-effective.

The emphasis here on economics should not give the impression that open-ground plants are in anyway inferior to the more expensive container-raised plants. On the contrary, the root systems of the later are frequently compromised due to root circling, resulting in poor growth prospects for such specimens. Bare-rooted plants, however, must be planted within days of being lifted from their open-ground beds. While this is standard forestry practice and presents few problems in large well-managed projects, the method is less well suited to small casually managed volunteer projects.

Mahurangi Action is encouraged by the New Zealand Transport Agency’s response to its request that open-ground raised plants be considered for use in the proposed project, as per designation condition 36c viii:

Consideration of the suitability of sourcing planting raised via the open-ground forestry method, including availability and cost-effectiveness

Ideally, should the project proceed, large-scale trails involving at least 100‍ ‍000 plants would be established—ten times the number involved in the Taupö trials. The trials would pay for themselves in reduced plant and planting costs. Again, ideally, an even greater percentage of open-ground plants would be deployed, and with the savings a greater area be planted. An example of such an area is where the designated route runs close by the Mahurangi River, south branch, in the vicinity of Valerie Close. The agency currently plans to build an access between the proposed motorway and the river. Instead, this area should be retired from grazing and be reforested with indigenous species to create a broad riparian management zone.


Pieces on the proposed motorway
Only Honourable Option to Oppose in Full
Mahurangi Action Contributes Motorway Designation Condition 36c viii
Headwater Streams of the Mahurangi Estimated Not Measured
Mahurangi Harbour Urgently Needs to Sign All the Friends She Has Already
Pühoi–Warkworth Motorway Proposal Harbour’s Biggest Threat Since Deforestation
Shweeb and/or Trail Saving Rail
Aside from Highway a Reasonable Plan
Make Existing Highway Safer Spend Balance on Christchurch
Time to Submit for Better Transport
Rodney Seat Shapes Up as Green Transport Battleground
Billion-Dollar Motorway Flyover
Other Than Motorway What 2.3 Billion Buys
Goodbye Old Motorway Hello New Rail
Safety First Trumps Weak Economics
First Phase Submission
Motorway Extension All Right for Some
Just the Place to Stop the Motorway
Mahurangi May Need to Take One for the Team
Motorway: Think On
Thinking a Little Beyond 26 July
Fossil-Fuel Solutions, Stratospheric Cost
Never Fear to Negotiate
Smarter Models Gagging For It
Alternatives to the Agency Model
Planning for the New Coast Road
Mahurangi Might Dodge Another Bullet

Regional Council’s Informal Position
Email address (will not appear online)
Audience (for editor only / for publication / request to be notified of new content)

Kindly enter the text displayed below
Honest comment that makes its point quickly and politely is valued.
Comment is moderated and may be edited for clarity.

Part of a hope-based network restoring and enjoying the Mahurangi
 Editor Cimino Cole